top of page

The West Philippine Sea: Defending Our Waters Without Becoming a U.S. Forward Base

Nov 10
2 min read

Filipino fishers have been chased, rammed and blasted with water cannons in their own waters. Filipino sailors have been boarded and attacked. China's aggression in the West Philippine Sea is real, and it has to be resisted. But there's a second danger that gets far less attention: using the crisis to turn the Philippines into a forward base for U.S. military power.


What China Has Done


  • 2012: Scarborough Shoal. After a standoff, China took effective control of the shoal, a traditional fishing ground for Filipinos.

  • 2016: The ruling. On July 12, 2016, an arbitral tribunal under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea ruled in the Philippines' favor and rejected China's sweeping “nine-dash line” claims. China refused to recognize it.

  • Ayungin Shoal. Since 1999, a handful of Filipino marines have lived aboard the BRP Sierra Madre, a rusting ship deliberately grounded on Ayungin (Second Thomas) Shoal to hold the Philippine claim. China has repeatedly blocked their resupply missions.

  • June 17, 2024. China Coast Guard personnel armed with bladed weapons boarded Philippine resupply boats at Ayungin, seized rifles and injured Filipino sailors. One sailor lost his thumb.


These are attacks on Filipino sovereignty, and Filipinos are right to be angry.


But Is the U.S. Defending Us?


Washington says it's defending the Philippines. Look closer at what it's actually doing. EDCA sites have been placed in northern Luzon, facing Taiwan, not just near the West Philippine Sea. A U.S. missile system was deployed to Luzon in 2024. These moves fit America's strategy to contain China. They don't put fish on Filipino tables.


History also gives reason for caution. During the 2012 Scarborough standoff, a U.S.-brokered arrangement was supposed to have both sides pull back. The Philippines withdrew. China stayed. The U.S. didn't force China out.


Sovereignty means refusing to be anyone's battleground, whether the flag is Chinese or American.

Who Really Pays


If a war breaks out between the U.S. and China, the Philippines will be on the front line. U.S. sites and missiles on our soil make our cities targets. Our fishers, our soldiers and our families would pay the price for a conflict decided in Washington and Beijing.


An Independent Path


  • Stand on the 2016 ruling. Use international law and diplomacy, and build support among other Southeast Asian countries with claims of their own.

  • Protect Filipino fishers first. Fund the coast guard, support fishing communities and keep traditional fishing grounds open to them.

  • Build self-reliant defense. A country that makes its own ships and equipment doesn't need to rent out its land.

  • Reject foreign bases. No U.S. bases, no Chinese bases. An independent foreign policy, as the Constitution intends.


Defending the West Philippine Sea and opposing U.S. militarization aren't contradictions. They come from the same place: a Philippines that belongs to Filipinos.


Related Reading



Sources


Comments


bottom of page